Balancing Profits and Purpose: The Rise of ESG Proxy Voting

Balancing Profits and Purpose: The Rise of ESG Proxy Voting

ESG proxy voting is rapidly emerging as a tool that shareholders are using to find a balance between profit maximisation and social impact. With environmental, social and governance (ESG) concerns in the limelight, the traditional boardroom proxy vote, once a mere formality, is now a powerful instrument for change. Diligent recently explored how ESG proxy voting is changing the boardroom.

Over the years, the emphasis on ESG has dramatically influenced shareholder sentiment, reshaping the boardroom and the very nature of proxy seasons. To navigate this evolving landscape, it’s crucial for boards to have a deep understanding of what ESG proxy voting entails, the various issues driving it, its historical trends, and the common guidelines associated with it. Also, boards need to know how best to manage these ESG-related proxy votes.

Proxy voting has always been a way for shareholders to voice their opinions, even if they cannot attend annual meetings. The rise of ESG has, however, converted proxy voting into a formidable weapon for shareholders. Some boards were slow to act on ESG matters, leading to an increase in shareholder activists using proxy voting to further their ESG objectives. The result? Boards now sit up and take notice due to the significant sway ESG matters can have on board proposals.

Certain ESG concerns influence proxy voting more than others. For instance, the 2023 proxy season saw a 3% rise in social proposals compared to 2022, and a staggering 24% rise compared to 2021, with diversity being a prime focus. There’s also been a notable surge in compensation-related proposals, especially in light of the new Dodd-Frank rules linking pay with performance. Furthermore, the period between 2009 and 2022 saw close to 1,000 climate-related proposals initiated by shareholders, underscoring the importance placed on environmental considerations.

Shareholder activists, for decades, have used their shares to influence company decisions. The popularity of ESG proxy voting has added a potent tool to their arsenal. This activism was evident during the 2023 proxy season, with corporate titans like Disney and Salesforce facing proxy challenges. However, the connection between ESG and proxy voting isn’t always straightforward, with corporations evolving in their responses.

The landscape of ESG proxy voting and shareholder activism will likely be influenced by the introduction of the universal proxy card by the SEC in 2022, wider acceptance of ESG policies, and more strategic board management backed by modern proxy insights tools.

Institutional investors, like BlackRock, have also showcased their support for ESG through their proxy voting guidelines. These guidelines touch on several key areas, such as board governance, mergers and acquisitions, and sustainability.

Preparation for ESG proxy voting isn’t just confined to the proxy season; it’s a year-round endeavour. Effective boards anticipate shareholder concerns, ensuring they don’t escalate into contentious proposals. A few strategies include transparent compensation disclosures, enhanced board effectiveness, a genuine commitment to board diversity, implementing actionable ESG strategies, and utilising proxy insights to gauge shareholder sentiments.

In conclusion, boards that are proactive and attuned to investor sentiments will be best positioned to navigate the intricate world of ESG proxy voting. Although the ESG journey may seem complex, the right data and insights can provide a clear roadmap that aligns business objectives with shareholder expectations.

Read the full story here.

Keep up with all the latest FinTech news here

Copyright © 2023 FinTech Global

Enjoying the stories?

Subscribe to our daily FinTech newsletter and get the latest industry news & research


The following investor(s) were tagged in this article.